American music that became prominent in the 20th century often evolved in response to what came before. Some artists who believed that popular music was cloyingly sweet decided to give it an edge and made it louder or angrier. Some of them couldn’t stand the polished sound of the established artists, so they composed what sounded grittier and far more textured.
Similarly, flamboyant maximalism was replaced by stripped-down displays of emotion, and simplicity was challenged by intricate compositions that experimented with form and structure. Yet, no matter how the music changed, if it echoed the public sentiment at the time, it became popular. Often, it represented what the younger generation was hungry for at that time.
Eraserheads, the Philippine rock band, rose to fame due to the same hunger in the mid-1980s. Maria Diane Ventura’s recent documentary, “Eraserheads: Combo on the Run,” explores their journey from the late 1980s when the band was formed to the recent past when they decided to get back together for a live show. Back then, the Philippine youth was looking for a respite from their precarious past as they were heading into a new era of democracy.
The band’s music acted like a balm to their sorrows, thanks to their relatable lyrics. Their songs often explored mundane details, which spoke to a generation yearning for the simple pleasures of life. It might be something as casual as taking a stroll around a campus or spending time with their soulmates, but it meant so much to the younger generation because they craved that sort of comfort.
That doesn’t mean they were technically the most proficient musicians from their era. Even the band members accept this while being interviewed for the documentary. Their music didn’t sound as complex or profound as their contemporaries, which made some people wonder why they were getting so much attention from people.
This was a time long before streaming or online piracy, which means record sales mattered far more in a different context. That’s when the band drew huge crowds to their shows, playing what appealed to them. That popularity paved the way for them to get a record deal and go on to become one of the most beloved bands from their country.
Ventura’s film analyzes their journey in a classic music documentary structure. It focuses on the band’s growth as a group of creatives who had a falling out along the way. So, it’s primarily a film about the band’s shared history that offers a peek into their personal lives.
It gives the band members, Ely Buendia, Raimund Marasigan, Buddy Zabala, and Marcus Adoro, an opportunity to speak their mind about everything that led to the pitfalls of their past. They speak about events from the last three decades, wistfully but more maturely than before. Instead of holding grudges, they pour their heart out, replacing bitterness with compassion.
Some of its most evocative moments come from the times they discuss their conflicting relationship with fame. It’s a tale as old as time, at least since capitalism has shaped our world. If something gets popular, people want that.
More often, they want it exactly like that. For a band like Eraserheads, that meant limiting themselves to the ideas fans had about them instead of relying on their artistic expression. It also means expecting them to repeat what made them popular.
Since the audience demands that, the record label would want to monetize it. In the band’s case, that means recreating the magic of a song that became a social anthem of sorts. While speaking about this topic, Ely says something that would resonate with many creatives: You can’t always recreate the magic.
Most times, these things are out of your control. While not a novel thought in itself, it takes you closer to understanding the human behind the creative. Nonetheless, the film can’t escape a sense of familiarity in some shape or form.
Ventura, who wrote the script with Aldus Santos and Chuck Gutierrez, structures it in a way reminiscent of many similar projects. In its earliest moments, it shows the bandmates getting ready to speak in front of the camera in a way that’s been done plenty of times. Even “Daisy Jones & the Six,” a fictional mockumentary show about a fictional band from the 1970s, follows this exact pattern.
That works in the show’s favor because it evokes nostalgia for what would probably be considered the golden age of bands in the US, but it doesn’t feel as charming or effortless in the documentary. It also doesn’t help that the film doesn’t dwell on the contentious details about Marcus Adoro’s familial past. The recent fictional biopics have gotten flak for disregarding similar details, so it feels odd for a documentary not to analyze its intricacies.
It feels like that topic is brushed under the rug, which makes the film lean more into a hagiography. Besides that, I felt the film could have touched upon the topic of the stylistic influences on the band’s sound. Even the recent by-the-numbers Br