Apr 25, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Detroit Tigers pitcher Jack Flaherty (9) throws against the Cincinnati Reds in the first inning at Great American Ball Park. Mandatory Credit: Aaron Doster-Imagn Images | Aaron Doster-Imagn Images Jack Flaherty had zero command of anything in this one and was mauled for six runs in two innings of work. Even accounting for Flaherty’s usual rollercoaster nature, this is two in a row where he really couldn’t put the fastball remotely where he wanted it with any consistency.

Kevin McGonigle and Spencer Torkelson homered early on, but the Tigers offense couldn’t put together a rally as they dropped their second in a row to the Reds in Cincinnati on Saturday. This one started off auspiciously and in classic Great American Ballpark fashion, as Kevin McGonigle got a 1-0 sinker away from Brady Singer, and hammered it into the seats for his second major league home run. Perhaps he felt the pressure to maintain his lead in Baseball Reference’s WAR metric.

Good to see his right hand was alright after getting hit last night. View LinkMatt Vierling grounded out, but Colt Keith slapped a single up the middle and Riley Greene followed with an oppo roller to the left side that went for a hit as well. Dillon Dingler grounded one in the hole and the Reds could only get the out at second.

So it was first and third with two outs to Kerry Carpenter. Singer fell behind in the count but eventually Carpenter flew out to end the inning, stranding two. Jack Flaherty started his day by striking out TJ Friedl, but he quickly fell behind Matt McLain and walked him and did the same with Elly De La Cruz.

Bad Jack continues, and in this park a lack of control is a disaster. I wrote that last sentence before Sal Stewart hammered a 1-1 slider down over the middle for a three-run shot and a 3-0 lead. Nathaniel Lowe launched a solo shot to make it 4-1.

Flaherty still had just one out, and he was going to have to wear this. Spencer Steer would have to wear something as well, as he then got plunked, bringing Chris Fetter to the mound as this was trending toward a bullpen game as Flaherty was already over 30 pitches. Tyler Stephenson took a called strike three, and Will Benson whiffed on a knuckle curve to end the inning. 4-1 Reds.The Tigers went in order, and Ke”Bryan Hayes started the bottom of the second by hammering a first pitch fastball to the wall in center field for a double.

Friedl dropped a good bunt toward third base, but Colt Keith made a nice play to get him at first. Still, it did the job of advancing Hayes to third. Flaherty got away with a 3-2 meatball of a slider that McLain whiffed on.

Flaherty’s velocity continued to swing wildly as his mechanics from 89.5-95.2 mph. De La Cruz got into a 2-2 count and smoked a curveball for a deep drive to center field. 6-1 Reds.Even before De La Cruz’s homer, this was already looking like the kind of game where you just want Flaherty to take an absolute beating if that’s what it takes to get four innings out of him and not hurt the bullpen too much. Coming back to win wasn’t really in the cards unless Singer fell apart entirely.

Stewart was called out on strikes, but it wasn’t really close, and a challenge quickly overturned that. After an 11 pitch AB, he snoked a hot grounder that McGonigle could only dive for and keep in the infield for a single. After back-to-back disasters, Dillon Dingler apparently remembered that you need to pitch Nate Lowe up and in, finally getting a ground out to end the inning as RHP Burch Smith warmed in the Tigers’ bullpen.

I won’t bore you with Flaherty’s line. It suffices to say it sucked, and you had to think his night was already over. McGonigle led off the third by lining a cutter to center field for a single.

Matt Vierling lined out to right, and Keith made an oppo bid with a drive to left that just fell short for the second out of the inning. Riley Greene continues to swing it great, ripping a hot one-hopper through the right side for a single that got McGonigle to third. Singer did the right thing with Dingler, staying down away from him with breaking balls.

A ground out to second ended the threat. Burch Smith’s outing didn’t begin well as he walked Steer. The veteran right-hander’s power curve got Stephenson to lift a routine fly out, and he froze Benson with a fastball for strike three.

Hayes whiffed on a good curveball down, and we were on to the fourth. Kerry Carpenter was ahead in the count to open the inning, but he whiffed on a sinker on the outer edge. Spencer Torkelson however, got a first pitch heater and killed it to right center field for his fourth home run of the year and fourth in as many days.

The Tigers record is five straight from Marcus Thames in 2008. 6-2 Reds. Nice to see an oppo shot. Tork’s approach has been very good this year and he’s finally reaping the rewards. View LinkWenceel Pérez has been putting the ball in play a ton with horrific luck, but he got a sweeper and pulled it to right for a on